Total Eclipse of the Heart, For Shame!

I was introduced to two different versions of the video for this song. The song's an epic in 80's power ballads, and Bonnie Tyler (even though I know only two of her songs) was brilliant with feathered blonde hair. I wanted to showcase the actual video for your viewing:


I want to say that the guy that directed Meatloaf's video "I would Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)" directed this one, but I'm just not sure. The video is a train wreck, and I think that's why I love it. It's trying to be epic, but it has shortcomings. Now, I wanted to show you the literal meaning of the video:


Which one do you like better?